mNo edit summary |
JamesKalbach (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| Line 66: | Line 66: | ||
We've merged the live search with the address bar as shown in the third demonstration video. | We've merged the live search with the address bar as shown in the third demonstration video. | ||
==Mentor Comments== | |||
===James Kalbach=== | |||
'''Concept''' | |||
- In larger projects teams and within organizations, the ability to communicate design clearly and succinctly is very important. The problem definition for this project is unclear and includes many different aspects: bookmark toolbar, relevance, clear design, using folders. I’d like to hear a more focused statement about the issue you’re addressing. | |||
- What type of “research” did you conduct, with how many people, and with whom? | |||
- The essence of your project statement is more than 140 characters. It should just include who, what, where, why, when and how. Perhaps something like: “Our solution intends to help average web users better organize, arrange and re-find bookmarks they’ve created in a local browser.” | |||
'''Implementation''' | |||
- The explanation of the solution is well done. The video in particular is very good and goes a long way in illustrating the intent of your project. | |||
- I would have liked to have heard more about existing solutions for bookmarking and a comparison of their capabilities and shortcomings against your idea. | |||
- The sorting features are good on the folders. | |||
- What happens if there is a very long list of bookmarks in a given folder? Does the menu extend beyond the page fold at the bottom of the browser? What are the limits to the number of bookmarks that can put in a folder? | |||
- Did you consider filtering bookmarks in addition to just sorting them? | |||
- What alternative directions did you explore before arriving at this solution? | |||
'''User tests''' | |||
- Please describe more about the tests you conducted, including an indication of the method, users, and findings. | |||
Overall, this is a well-thought-out project that really shows you paid attention to the detail of interaction design and the overall experience. | |||